This project addressed rockfall hazards resulting from longwall undermining of the Twentymile Sandstone Cliff in northwest Colorado.  Although there have been numerous studies of rockfall hazards and rockfall control in the Rocky Mountains, this project is considered unique due primarily to the anticipated size of the boulders and the need to prevent boulders from reaching a nearby county road.

The  Foidel  Creek  Mine  currently extracts  coal  using 245m wide longwall panels, between 250m and 275m below ground level.  The Twenymile Sandstone outcrop forms a prominent cliff between 15 and 70m high, running for many  miles  through  the  mining district. With a coal extraction thickness of some 2.4m, subsidence analysis predicted that sections of the cliff would fail during undermining. 

Fieldwork was carried out during the summer of 1994, and involved geotechnical assessment of the cliff and the foreslope.  The critical factors to be assessed were the range of potential block-sizes which could be released from the cliff and the nature of the foreslope, in particular its topography, roughness, and frictional and restitution coefficients.

Block-sizes were assessed using scanline mapping to provide statistical data on discontinuity spacings and orientations.  The probable ranges of block volumes and key dimensions were calculated from these distributions using the simulation program @RISK.  This analysis indicated some very large potential block sizes.

Rockfall hazard analysis was carried out using the Colorado  Rockfall Simulation  Program  (CRSP3) developed jointly  by  the  Colorado Transportation Institute, Colorado Department of Transportation, and the Colorado Geological Survey. 

CRSP3 uses Monte Carlo simulation to predict the probable size, mass, velocity and height of falling rocks at any user-specified point on the slope.  Input includes the slope cross section, the range of block sizes and shapes, and the slope surface characteristics assessed during site investigation.  The output can be used directly in the design of barriers, catch ditches and other protection measures, should the analysis indicate these are needed.

Some  twenty  critical  sections  were identified and analysed using CRSP3.  For each section  a  thousand  rockfall  scenarios  were analysed to provide the probabilistic output. 

Back-analyses  of  known  rockfalls  were  used to calibrate the models, ensuring  the  slope  surface characteristics were appropriate. The results  were  presented  as  a hazard map contoured at specific risk levels.  Where the map indicated unacceptable risk, rockfall protection was designed.

In view of the potential size of the blocks involved, the use of conventional rockfall protection fences was ruled out.  Instead, a system of rock traps, consisting of trenches and earth berms, was designed. The depth, width and face angles of these traps were checked using CRSP3, and modified as needed until the program indicated a extremely low probability of boulders escaping.

As a result, approximately 915m of 6m-deep trench was constructed between County Road 27 and the Twentymile Cliff to intercept and contain falling boulders.  In addition, a 460m section of the road was realigned  to  enable  construction  of the rockfall protection measures.  The total cost of the works was about US$1M.

A short section of the cliff subsequently failed during undermining and  many large blocks were released.  Approximately twenty boulders ranging in weight from 10 to 820 tonnes traversed the foreslope and were stopped by the trench.   The protection measures  were  constructed  in  natural soils from the site, and  vegetation  cover  quickly developed such that the works are scarcely noticeable from the highway. 

Project awarded the 1998 Colorado Coal Mine Reclaimation Division Environmental Award.

Back to Projects

A PDF version of this case study is available on the download page


[Home] [Mining] [Tunnels] [No-Dig] [Slopes] [SI] [Site Map] [Contact Us]